Publications

Explore articles, jobs, talks, news, privacy,...

Learn about dark patterns, fair patterns and much more

Willing to dig further on dark patterns? Here are curated resources, including hundreds of publications we analyzed in our R&D Lab, conferences, webinars and job opportunities to fight dark patterns.

Evan Caragay, Katherine Xiong, Jonathan Zong and Daniel Jackson

In the framework, the report has redefined the concept of dark patterns in user interface design. They focused on the interaction between users and applications, grounded in user expectations and the reuse of common concepts. Design is considered "dark" when it intentionally violates these expectations to benefit the application provider. Through case studies, they demonstrated how this concept-based analysis can help designers identify and address such issues. They propose a shift away from traditional taxonomies of dark patterns towards a more systematic, actionable approach to ethical interface design.
Website cookie dialogs are common for safeguarding user privacy, but many employ manipulative tactics, known as dark patterns, to make it harder for users to opt out. These tactics violate privacy laws and can lead to fines, as seen with Google and Meta in 2022. The paper "DarkDialogs" presents an automated tool that detects 10 dark patterns in cookie dialogs with high accuracy, highlighting the prevalence of such practices.

Suvi Lehtosalo and Daniel W. Woods

The study investigates compliance with privacy laws like Article 8 GDPR and CCPA on children's websites. They analyzed 2,066 educational and gaming websites, finding that only a minority address consent dialogs for children. This suggests potential non-compliance with GDPR, raising concerns about data protection for young users.

Kerstin Bongard-Blanchy , Jean-Louis Sterckx , Arianna Rossi , Anastasia Sergeeva , Vincent Koenig , Salvador Rivas , Verena Distler

This paper investigates the impact of "loss-gain framing" as a dark pattern strategy on user data disclosure behavior in mobile settings. Understanding how framing affects users' willingness to share personal information is essential for privacy policy development and user interface design. In an online user study involving 848 participants, they tested different framings (positive, negative, neutral) of app permission requests. Surprisingly, negative framing increased disclosure rates, while positive framing reduced them, possibly due to heightened suspicion. These findings carry implications for designing interfaces that promote informed, privacy-conscious decision-making.

John King, Dan Fitton, Brendan Cassidy

This research aims to uncover and categorize deceptive design practices within 3D environments commonly found in PC games. Through a survey involving 259 adult respondents, we identified six distinct categories of deceptive design patterns within a popular free-to-play 3D game: Predatory Monetization, Default to Purchase, UI Misdirection, Emotional Interpersonal Persuasion, Physical Placement, and Narrative Obligation. This work is vital as 3D and VR gaming gain momentum, and the gaming industry increasingly adopts "freemium" monetization models. It highlights the importance of understanding and addressing deceptive design in this evolving gaming landscape.

Martin Brenncke

In the evolving landscape of online commerce, dark patterns pose a significant challenge, blurring the line between persuasion and manipulation. This Article focuses on the European Union's legal response to these issues, highlighting the need to protect consumer autonomy. It introduces a novel framework that classifies dark patterns into six categories of autonomy violations, providing policymakers with a clear path to regulate and safeguard consumers' decision-making independence.

Reza Ghaiumy Anaraky*, Byron Lowens, Yao Li, Kaileigh A. Byrne, Marten Risius, Xinru Page, Pamela Wisniewski, Masoumeh Soleimani, Morteza Soltani, and Bart Knijnenburg

In the realm of online privacy, dark patterns are design strategies that often lead users to disclose more information than they intend. The research, focusing on older adults (above 65) and young adults (18-25), reveals the effectiveness of these dark patterns. Positive framing and opt-out privacy defaults increase disclosure behavior, while negative justifications reduce privacy concerns. Notably, older adults show both increased disclosure and heightened privacy concerns when exposed to these strategies. Privacy concerns, however, do not hinder disclosure, highlighting the potential risks dark patterns pose, especially to older users. This raises important ethical questions about safeguarding digital privacy for all age groups.

Carla Sousa and Ana Oliveira

In today's digitalized society, mobile digital games (MDGs) play a pivotal role in early childhood education. However, concerns about problem gaming and unethical design patterns in MDGs for young children have emerged. The analysis of the top five free games for ages 0-5 on the App Store (February 2023) revealed the presence of temporal, monetary, and psychological dark patterns. These include aesthetic manipulations, paywalls, and elements resembling gambling rewards. The study emphasizes the need for digital literacy and responsible game design to ensure healthier gaming experiences for young children.

Gijs Kopmeiners

The study focuses on a specific dark pattern within cookie consent dialogs on websites: the absence of a clear opt-out option alongside the opt-in choice. This pattern was investigated across five European countries by crawling 23,303 websites. The findings were striking: 13,522 websites had an accept option, but only 6,016 had a reject option on the initial layer. This suggests that more than half of the websites they analyzed employed this dark pattern, potentially violating GDPR and highlighting the need for improved ethical design practices.

Our clients